Previous Finalists





Comments from Authors/Publishers



271 Comments from Authors/Publishers



Hi Mr. Trayer,

I am so grateful for the feedback I received from your amazing readers! I am impressed with their maturity, dedication, and honesty. I am sure all of these teens are very busy with a multitude of activities, the least of which is their education; taking precious time to read our novels to offer genuine and heartfelt feedback is awe inspiring.

Yes! Please post the readers'Comments, Catchy Quote, Stats and Star Rating on Goodreads.com and, if it's
listed, Bookbub.com for me.

I am deep into writing book two in the series right now and this feedback is very helpful! I've added some of these quotes for the marketing that you all are doing for Keepers.

On another note, I hope Wishing Shelf continues to grow and gain strength in equal measure. If I can somehow assist from across the pond in sunny CA, please let me know!

E. K. Wise, author of The Debilis Rising (Keepers of the Rock)


THANK YOU to everyone who took the time to read through so many wonderful books.
I cannot tell you how thrilled my illustrator and I am to have the honor of being among this incredible list of authors.
We love what you all do, with the donations and the fact that you have such a variety of judges including kids and teens. That is why you are my favourite yearly competition... you have real folks of all ages and walks of life giving their valuable two cents.

Yvette Farkas, author of Ethan and the Seven Chakras


It's cliché to say but this has far exceeded my expectations. Thank you so much for organising this competition and getting my book out there to so many people, Edward. I loved reading the reviews and being a part of The Wishing Shelf Awards. I would also love for those reviews to be posted on the Goodreads page too. They were all so kind and definitely triggered some emotions.

Thanks again for all that you do.

Hayden Perno, author of Ralph Ridley in the Hunt for Time


The readers' comments are thoughtful and critiqued with respect, but most importantly, they all "got" the story. I'm delighted with the WS service provided. Their comments will absolutely make my next MG/YA better. If you get a chance, please let them know.
As you stated, go ahead and publish the reviews wherever. Keep up all the excellent work.

Nan Evenson, author of Walk On


Thank you for sending this feedback on Connecting Threads: Five Siblings Lost and Found. It was very moving to read the readers' comments about the book. These comments mean so much to me. It's important to know that the story carries some strength and a sense of hope for the readers who reviewed it. Very thoughtful and touching comments. Much gratitude to everyone! And I'm glad to know the cover needs some work.

E M Blake, author of Connecting Threads


1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Next > >


Sponsored Ads



Angry Arthur
and The Run Around Trick
Learn to manage big feelings
Amazon


“Hatch Chile Willie”
offers children a heartwarming
tale of friendship
Amazon


The Third Estate
WHEN THE TRUTH SURFACES
AND THE LIES are REVEALED
Amazon


ELLA'S WAR
Heart-stopping, spirit-lifting
award-winning historical novel
vineleavespress


The Faraway Mountains
A memorable novel about
growing up under dictatorship
Amazon


The Halloween Candy MONSTER
Jimmy teaches the Halloween
candy monster a lesson
Amazon


MOTHER TO ELEPHANTS
A heartwarming, inspiring kids
picture book biography
THE STORY OF DAPHNE SHELDRICK


DEAR JAMES
I know it's been 20 years, but
I needed to tell you I'm sorry
Amazon


Glitching Souls - Steve Kenney
Neil can read minds...
He can't turn them off.
Amazon


THE GRAVITY OF LIES
WHAT IF YOUR WHOLE LIFE
WAS BASED ON LIES?
Amazon


Jemma and the Raven
A luminous adventure in
this epic YA fantasy debut
Amazon


The Pathology of Graphology
Two citizens of the lower
depths kill an aging DJ.
by David Milnes





From B to A:Britain to Albania
Funny road trip memoir–
with 4 dogs & 1 big truck!
by Jacqueline Lambert


QUACK ALONG WITH ZACK, MACK, A
AND JACK - 3 adventurous ducks
learn to share
A FUN PICTURE BOOK


THE GRAVITY OF LIES
WHAT IF YOUR WHOLE LIFE
WAS BASED ON LIES?
Amazon


Aunty Jane Knits Up A Storm
Knitting, Friendship, Loss &
Healing in a Children's Story
Amazon